For Brands

Is AI Recommending Your Competitors Instead of You?

When someone asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, or Gemini for the best option in your category, your brand either shows up or it doesn't. We studied 3,733 businesses across five AI models to learn exactly which signals decide that — then we run them for you and measure the lift.

The Shift

Search is splitting in two. Your brand needs to show up in both.

Google still matters. But a growing number of buying decisions now start with an AI conversation, not a search bar.

Traditional Search

Google ranks pages

10 blue links. Your SEO team optimises meta tags, builds backlinks, and fights for page one. You've been doing this for years.

#1Your competitor's homepage
#2Reddit thread comparing options
#3Quora answer from 2024
#4Your homepage
AI-Powered Search

AI recommends brands

One answer. No scrolling. The AI picks who to recommend based on what it's learned from forums, reviews, and news. There is no page two.

“What's the best project management tool for remote teams?”

Based on community discussions and user reviews, the top options are Competitor A, Competitor B, and Competitor C.

Your brand? Not mentioned.

The Cost of Invisibility

Every day AI doesn't recommend you, your competitor gets stronger

AI models lean on the same trusted sources over and over. In our baseline study (n=1,004), 65.9% of businesses were completely invisible to AI. When your competitor holds the signals that earn citations and you don't, that gap compounds.

Invisible pipeline leak

Potential customers ask AI for recommendations, get your competitor's name, and never google you. You don't even know the lead existed.

Compounding advantage

AI models reinforce what they already know. The more authority signals your competitor accumulates — directories, reviews, the pages AI cites — the more likely AI is to recommend them next time.

The window is closing

Right now most brands haven't figured this out. That won't last. The brands that build AI visibility now will be the ones AI recommends for years to come.

How It Works

We dose the signals your category responds to — and measure every move

Our research decomposed AI visibility into measurable off-page signals. We run the highest-leverage ones for your vertical, then track whether AI actually starts recommending you.

1. Measure your baseline

We probe ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, and Google's AI with your buying-intent prompts to score your share of model today — and audit the off-page signals our research links to citations. Not guesswork — data.

2. Fix entities & directories

Directory and entity presence was the single strongest off-page predictor in our second study — ahead of Domain Authority. We make your identity consistent across the directories, schema, and knowledge graphs AI reads.

3. Build reviews & cited sources

Review volume was a top single predictor in study one. And on the AI surfaces that show their sources, being the page that's cited tracked with a 5.5× lift in mention probability — so we work to make that source yours. Selective forum participation supports this where the vertical rewards it.

4. Measure the lift

Track how often AI recommends your brand vs. competitors across every major model. Share of model is the new share of voice — and we tie every movement back to the signal that caused it.

Built on evidence

Measurement, not promises

Every engagement starts with a baseline audit, then re-measures as the work lands. The signals we prioritise aren't hunches — they come from two published studies of 3,733 businesses across five AI models.

What the AI Visibility Index research found

r = 0.391

Directory presence was the #1 off-page predictor of AI visibility in study two — ahead of Domain Authority itself.

5.5×

On AI surfaces that return source URLs, being the cited source tracked with a 5.5× lift in mention probability.

65.9%

Of 1,004 businesses in the baseline study, two-thirds were completely invisible to AI — zero mentions across five models.

30×

How much off-page leverage varied between verticals — so we triage the stack to your category, not a fixed checklist.

n=1,004

study one businesses

n=2,729

study two businesses

5 models

tracked side-by-side

study 3

controlled trial, in recruitment

Studies 1 and 2 are observational and published. Study 3 — the controlled, before-and-after intervention trial — is now in recruitment, with results published regardless of direction. See the research.

What You Get

Everything a brand needs to own AI recommendations

AI Visibility Audit with a composite score and prioritised, vertical-aware action plan

Share of model tracking across ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, and Google AI Overview

Entity and directory consistency across Google, LinkedIn, and the sources AI reads

Review velocity guidance on the platforms AI weights most

Competitor monitoring so you know exactly who AI recommends instead

Work to make your pages the source AI cites on URL-returning surfaces

Selective forum and press support, weighted to where your vertical rewards it

Monthly progress reports tying each movement back to the signal that caused it

Get Started

Find out if AI recommends you

Start with a free AI Visibility Audit — you'll know your score, see where your competitors appear, and get a prioritised plan. Or start the Get-Cited Sprint and we'll run the work with you over six weeks, measured against a matched control group so you can see the lift we caused.

The audit is free, no credit card, results in about 20 minutes. Sprint cohort places are limited. Run an agency? See the agency use case